Cruiseable Plan my cruise

Ship comparison

American Independence vs Viking Astrild

The verdict

Which should you choose?

American Independence is an intimate American Cruise Lines ship carrying 92 passengers, in service since 2010. Viking Astrild is an intimate Viking River Cruises ship carrying 98 passengers, in service since 2015.

Choose American Independence if you want better-rated staterooms or more cruises to choose from: it outscores Viking Astrild for staterooms (8.0 vs 6.5) in Cruiseable’s Bliss scores and it has 10 cruises on sale (vs none).

Choose Viking Astrild if you want a more romantic trip, more space per passenger or a better-rated spa and gym: it outscores American Independence for romantic (7.0 vs 2.0) and spa & fitness (6.0 vs 4.0) in Cruiseable’s Bliss scores and it has 40.8 gross tons per passenger (vs 25.0).

Side by side

Specifications

marks the better figure where more, or less, is plainly better.

American IndependenceViking Astrild
Cruise line American Cruise Lines Viking River Cruises
Ship size Intimate Intimate
Maiden voyagenewer highlighted 2010 2015 (better)
Gross tonnage 2,300 4,000
Passengers 92 98
Crew 27 28
Passengers per crew memberfewer is better 3.4 (better) 3.5
Space per passengergross tons per passenger; more is roomier 25.0 40.8 (better)
Decks 4 3
Length 223 ft 361 ft
Beam 51 ft 36 ft
Speed — 17 mph
Cruiseable ratingout of 10 6 / 10 9 / 10 (better)
Cruises on sale 10 —
Upcoming sailings 93 —
Cruise lengths 8 to 11 nights —
Fares fromlower highlighted $4,610 —

Bliss scores

How they rate, out of 10

Cruiseable rates ships out of 10 on ten parts of a cruise holiday. American Independence leads on 1 of the ten, Viking Astrild on 6, with 3 level.

  • Active American Independence: 6.0 Viking Astrild: 7.0
  • Adventure & nature American Independence: 5.0 Viking Astrild: 5.0
  • Cultural American Independence: 6.0 Viking Astrild: 8.0
  • Dining American Independence: 5.0 Viking Astrild: 7.0
  • Entertainment American Independence: 6.0 Viking Astrild: 6.0
  • Family friendly American Independence: 4.0 Viking Astrild: 5.0
  • Party American Independence: 5.0 Viking Astrild: 5.0
  • Romantic American Independence: 2.0 Viking Astrild: 7.0
  • Spa & fitness American Independence: 4.0 Viking Astrild: 6.0
  • Staterooms American Independence: 8.0 Viking Astrild: 6.5

American Cruise Lines

American Independence

Maybe it's time to see more of the United States. American Cruise Lines offers a variety of options, including the American Independence, which cruises the Maine coast in summer and the Atlantic coast between South Carolina and Florida in winter. Fall cruisers can cruise the Hudson River for seasonal color and leaf peeping.

Highlights

  • New design features including Rolls Royce stabilizers make for a smoother cruise and less seasickness
  • Simple but comfortable, these ships were built to nestle into small coves and ports along the East Coast
  • Don't miss the crab and lobster served in the Chesapeake Bay and Maine regions!

Sailing now

10 cruises on sale, from $4,610.

Viking River Cruises

Viking Astrild

Designed to sail the shallow Elbe River between Prague and Berlin, the 98-passenger Viking Astrild has been dubbed a "baby Longship" because it's about half the size of the standard 190-passenger Viking Longships.

Highlights

  • Aquavit Terrace for al fresco dining
  • Observation Lounge features floor-to-ceiling windows for great river views
  • All staterooms are outside with a river view
  • Complimentary wi-fi

Questions

American Independence or Viking Astrild?

Which is bigger, American Independence or Viking Astrild?

Viking Astrild is bigger at 4,000 gross tons, against 2,300 gross tons for American Independence. American Independence carries 92 passengers and Viking Astrild carries 98.

Which ship is newer, American Independence or Viking Astrild?

Viking Astrild is newer, with a maiden voyage in 2015 against 2010 for American Independence.

Which has more space per passenger?

Viking Astrild, with 40.8 gross tons per passenger against 25.0 on American Independence. The higher the figure, the more ship there is for each guest.

Which has more crew per passenger?

American Independence, with one crew member for every 3.4 passengers against one for every 3.5 on Viking Astrild.

Which is better for families?

Viking Astrild scores higher for family friendliness in Cruiseable’s Bliss scores: 5.0 out of 10, against 4.0 for American Independence.

Still deciding?

Tell us what matters and we will match the sailing

Send your dates, budget and who is travelling, and our partner travel agency will come back to you about American Independence, Viking Astrild or a ship that suits you better.

Plan my cruise

Compare different ships