Cruiseable Plan my cruise

Ship comparison

American Serenade vs Viking Idun

The verdict

Which should you choose?

American Serenade is an intimate American Cruise Lines ship carrying 180 passengers, in service since 2023. Viking Idun is an intimate Viking River Cruises ship carrying 190 passengers, in service since 2012.

Choose American Serenade if you want more of a party, a better-rated spa and gym or more adventure and nature: it outscores Viking Idun for party (5.0 vs 1.0), spa & fitness (5.0 vs 2.0) and adventure & nature (5.0 vs 3.0) in Cruiseable’s Bliss scores.

Choose Viking Idun if you want better-rated dining or better-rated entertainment: it outscores American Serenade for dining (7.0 vs 6.0) and entertainment (6.0 vs 5.0) in Cruiseable’s Bliss scores.

Side by side

Specifications

marks the better figure where more, or less, is plainly better.

American SerenadeViking Idun
Cruise line American Cruise Lines Viking River Cruises
Ship size Intimate Intimate
Maiden voyagenewer highlighted 2023 (better) 2012
Gross tonnage 5,148 5,000
Passengers 180 190
Crew 43 50
Passengers per crew memberfewer is better 4.2 3.8 (better)
Space per passengergross tons per passenger; more is roomier 28.6 (better) 26.3
Decks 5 4
Length 269 ft 443 ft
Beam 56 ft 37 ft
Speed 14 mph 17 mph
Cruiseable ratingout of 10 9 / 10 9 / 10
Cruises on sale 11 7
Upcoming sailings 112 9
Cruise lengths 7 to 22 nights 7 to 11 nights
Fares fromlower highlighted $4,255 $3,599 (better)

Bliss scores

How they rate, out of 10

Cruiseable rates ships out of 10 on ten parts of a cruise holiday. American Serenade leads on 4 of the ten, Viking Idun on 2, with 4 level.

  • Active American Serenade: 7.0 Viking Idun: 7.0
  • Adventure & nature American Serenade: 5.0 Viking Idun: 3.0
  • Cultural American Serenade: 7.0 Viking Idun: 7.0
  • Dining American Serenade: 6.0 Viking Idun: 7.0
  • Entertainment American Serenade: 5.0 Viking Idun: 6.0
  • Family friendly American Serenade: 2.0 Viking Idun: 2.0
  • Party American Serenade: 5.0 Viking Idun: 1.0
  • Romantic American Serenade: 7.0 Viking Idun: 6.0
  • Spa & fitness American Serenade: 5.0 Viking Idun: 2.0
  • Staterooms American Serenade: 7.0 Viking Idun: 7.0

Viking River Cruises

Viking Idun

The 190-passenger Viking Idun features cruises through the heart of the Rhine Valley from the Netherlands through Germany and a piece of France and into Switzerland.

Highlights

  • Sun Deck with 360-degree views and shaded sitting area; organic herb garden and solar panels; putting green, chess and walking track
  • "Balcony" cabins have floor-to-ceiling slIdunng glass doors
  • Aquavit Terrace at the bow of the ship is great place to watch the river roll by
  • Ecologically friendly hybrid engines producing less vibrations for a smoother ride

Sailing now

7 cruises on sale, from $3,599.

Questions

American Serenade or Viking Idun?

Which is bigger, American Serenade or Viking Idun?

American Serenade is bigger at 5,148 gross tons, against 5,000 gross tons for Viking Idun. American Serenade carries 180 passengers and Viking Idun carries 190.

Which ship is newer, American Serenade or Viking Idun?

American Serenade is newer, with a maiden voyage in 2023 against 2012 for Viking Idun.

Which has more space per passenger?

American Serenade, with 28.6 gross tons per passenger against 26.3 on Viking Idun. The higher the figure, the more ship there is for each guest.

Which has more crew per passenger?

Viking Idun, with one crew member for every 3.8 passengers against one for every 4.2 on American Serenade.

Which is better for families?

They score the same for family friendliness in Cruiseable’s Bliss scores: 2.0 out of 10.

Still deciding?

Tell us what matters and we will match the sailing

Send your dates, budget and who is travelling, and our partner travel agency will come back to you about American Serenade, Viking Idun or a ship that suits you better.

Plan my cruise

Compare different ships